Give both builders the same starting point

Send the same dated drawings, specification and list of items you intend to buy yourself. If the drawings change during pricing, send the revision to everyone and ask which version their return covers. Otherwise a difference in the totals might simply be the old window arrangement in one quote and the new sliding doors in the other.

Read the preliminaries as well as the rooms. For roof work, for example, one builder may have included scaffolding hire and another may expect you to arrange it. Ask which elevations the allowance covers, how long the hire runs and what happens if the scaffold is needed for longer.

Follow an item until it is finished

“Underfloor heating included” is a good place to start asking questions. Are the manifold, controls and installation included? Who prices the screed and the finished floor above? The pipes in the Stone and Slate photographs show one stage of that sequence. A photograph of a finished room gives you little chance of spotting where one trade’s price ends.

Underfloor heating pipes running from a wall-mounted manifold across the unfinished floor.
Stone and Slate At this stage the pipework is visible. A quote for heating needs to say who supplies the controls and who prices the floor layers that follow.

Give each difference its own line

Here is an illustrative comparison for one tiled floor. Both quotes could mention tiling and still leave you with different bills.

Reading two tiling quotes
ItemQuote AQuote B
TilesSupply allowanceClient supplies
PreparationLevelling includedUnspecified
LayingLaying and grout includedLaying included, grout unspecified

For Quote B, get a price for the same tiles and ask the builder to confirm preparation and grout. For Quote A, check that the allowance covers the tiles you would actually choose. Compare the totals once both describe the floor you want, with VAT shown on the same basis.

New floor tiles with red and yellow levelling clips beside the garden glazing.
The Garden Room The levelling clips are still in place. A tile supply allowance alone tells you little about preparation, laying or finishing the edges.

Close the gaps in writing

Send each builder a short list of open points and ask for a revised quotation. Keep that response with the drawing set. Before agreeing to proceed, discuss the programme, payment stages and how a later change would be agreed and priced. Then your decision can take account of how each builder proposes to deliver the work as well as the total on the last page.